In the 2007 Nanjing Peng Yu Case, the Judge Said "If You Didn't Bump Into Him, Why Did You Help Him" and Ordered the Helper to Pay Compensation

In a 2007 case in Nanjing in which a person helped an elderly person who had fallen to the ground, the judge ordered the helper to pay compensation on the grounds that "if you didn't bump into him, why did you go and help him," and the ruling sparked nationwide discussion about extortion targeting those who act courageously to help others.

Evidence EVIDENCE

Sources 4 · Archived 0

SourceTypeReliabilityLink

一个狠人

2026-10-25 06:40

Media ●●●●●

Original

联合早报：上海赛场惊魂主办方致歉荷车手火海勇救对手

2026-10-25 06:40 · 此次事故中的赛道应急救援反应速度被批缓慢，在网上引发广泛质疑。

Web Source ●●●●●

Original

胡力任《真實中國》

2026-10-25 06:40 · 胡力任《真實中國》发布视频：道德淪喪的中共國社會已經沒有任何未來可言！分裂是唯一的出路。《真實中國》

Media ●●●●●

Original

李老师不是你老师

2026-10-25 06:40 · 9月5日，上海China GT赛事现场发生赛车撞击起火事故，救援人员疑因日薪仅60元而火灾中途离场，引发关注。

First-hand ●●●●●

Original

Context CONTEXT

Cause Not recorded yet

This event In the 2007 Nanjing Peng Yu Case, the Judge Said "If You Didn't Bump Into Him, Why Did You Help Him" and Ordered the Helper to Pay Compensation 2007 · Reported

Effect Not recorded yet

Coverage of this event COVERAGE

Article · 2026-09-10 02:41 A Shanghai track driver burned for 70 seconds in fire! He was saved by a passing opponent, security guards could not pull out the fire extinguisher safety pin, the live stream said the driver left the car on his own, 27 seconds to escape in Bahrain, 70 seconds in Shanghai! Daniel Wu angrily denounced it as shameful and withdrew from Chinese events, saving the brand first, then the narrative, and finally the person

Article · 2026-09-08 04:44 The Moral Collapse of CCP Society Has No Future! Division Is the Only Way. "Real China"

Sayings · 2026-09-07 12:40 September 5, at the Shanghai China GT event, a racing car collision caused a fire accident, and rescue personnel are suspected of leaving the scene midway due to a daily wage of only 60 yuan, sparking attention.

Report