反贼网
Machine translation · the Chinese original is authoritative · View original

Is it illegal for Musk to use a VPN to bypass the firewall in China?

1# · OP Author:張無忌 Published:2026-05-14 11:23 Replies:1 Views:94 Permalink:fanzei.net/d_2223ql

During his visit to China with Trump, Musk continuously used his phone to access X and post comments, including replying to the well-known dissident "Teacher Li is not your teacher." Does this behavior violate Chinese law?

According to China's "Interim Provisions on the Management of International Networking of Computer Information Networks," no unit or individual may independently establish or use channels not approved by the telecommunications management department (such as privately setting up or purchasing overseas VPN services) for international networking.

Corporate users: If multinational corporations need to use a VPN for business reasons, they must rent legal dedicated channels (i.e., commercial VPNs approved by the government) from telecommunications operators.

Individual users: Currently, there are no explicit exemption clauses for individual "wall-jumping" behavior. This means that, regardless of nationality, using unauthorized VPN services is a violation according to the legal provisions.

Related topics Chinese People Zhihei
Replies (1)
2026-05-20 19:16
核心争议:美欧之间的“数字外交战”
Freedom.gov 最戏剧性和最具争议的地方在于,它的主要针对目标除了传统的互联网审查国家(如中国、伊朗、俄罗斯)外,还首次公开包含了美国的西方盟友——欧洲(欧盟与英国)。

1. 欧美言论尺度的公开决裂
欧盟通过了《数字服务法案》(DSA),英国通过了《在线安全法案》,对网络上的仇恨言论、虚假信息、以及软色情或有害内容进行了极为严厉的监管和定向封锁。而美国当前的执政层(包括副总统万斯等人)则强烈批评欧洲的这些举措属于“媒体审查”。Freedom.gov 的目的之一就是让欧洲网民能绕过欧盟和英国的法律,直接看到被欧洲封锁的内容。

2. 盟友的强烈反弹与主权警告
该项目曝光后,欧洲政界和舆论引发了巨大反弹。欧盟议会和监管机构公开提出质疑,认为美国政府运营一个专门用来中和、破坏欧盟法律的 VPN 门户,是对欧洲数字主权的公然侵犯和“数字干涉”。

3. 数据隐私与“蜜罐”质疑
许多网络隐私专家和安全机构(如反虚假信息专家、隐私倡导组织)对自由网提出了强烈的怀疑。他们指出:

一个由美国情报与网络安全机构(CISA)托管的中央化 VPN,意味着所有流量都会暴露在美国《外国情报监视法案》(FISA 702)和《云法案》的管辖之下。

批评者认为,它本质上是一个披着“自由”外衣的国家级数据中转站(或被称为政治宣传工具),用户很难真正相信美国政府不会暗中监控这些海外流量。

现状:
尽管美国国务院发言人曾含糊其辞地否认“存在专门针对欧洲的反审查计划”,但 Freedom.gov 的网站和域名已经处于活跃状态。因为该项目在外交和法律层面的破坏性太大,其原定于2026年2月在慕尼黑安全会议上的公开亮相被无限期推迟,目前仍处于国际地缘政治舆论的风口浪尖。

Post a reply